⚖️ Comparison Guide

How to Choose Energy Monitoring Software? Excel vs SCADA vs EMS

We put Excel + the OSOS portal, SCADA / building automation and energy monitoring software side by side on 11 criteria. An approach comparison, not a brand comparison, with 10 questions to ask before you buy.

Enerji izleme yazılımı karşılaştırması — 6S Teknoloji canlı tüketim paneli

Three Common Approaches

Facilities track energy consumption in one of three ways today: following bills and the distribution company's OSOS portal in Excel, looking at the site's SCADA or building automation system, or using consumption-focused energy monitoring software (EMS). Each is strong at one job; trouble starts when the wrong tool is picked for the job.

This is not a brand comparison; we name no competitors and quote no competitor prices. The criteria are kept objective, and the 6S Teknoloji column lists only what the platform does today. Pricing details are on the pricing page, the full platform on the energy monitoring system page.

The Short Answer

  • Single site, single meter, monthly check: Excel + the OSOS portal may be enough
  • Operating and controlling equipment in real time: SCADA / building automation
  • Managing consumption in ₺ and seeing penalties before the bill: energy monitoring software
  • Multi-meter, multi-tenant or multi-site portfolio: energy monitoring software
  • Already have SCADA: an EMS runs alongside it, not instead of it

Side-by-Side Comparison

Each row is a topic to raise during purchasing. The SCADA column describes typical installations; individual projects may differ.

Criterion Excel + OSOS Portal SCADA / Building Automation Energy Monitoring Software (6S Teknoloji)
Data frequencyMonthly bill; OSOS load profile delayed on the portalReal time, on the operator screenRead interval configured per site; hourly and daily summaries stored
₺ reportingCalculated by handUsually none; kWh and kW focusedConsumption converted to ₺ with the tariff, month-end budget projection
Electricity + water + gasSeparate bills, separate filesMostly electrical and mechanical; water and gas need extra integrationAll three energy types on one panel
Warning before the billNone; problems show up on the billThreshold alarms, no billing contextEarly alarms for reactive ratio, peak demand and budget deviation
Tenant allocationManual spreadsheetUsually out of scopeSub-tenant billing from sub-meters
Meters readOnly the distribution company's main meterDevices wired into the projectModbus TCP/RTU, M-Bus, BACnet/IP, MQTT; BEDAŞ OSOS and İGDAŞ AVE integration
Explainable alarmsNone"Threshold exceeded" onlyRule-based alarms with the cause and the related measurement
When the connection dropsNot applicable (monthly data)Depends on local logging setupQueue + ACK on the field box, at least a 30-day buffer, zero data loss
Mobile accessFile sharingMostly a local screen; remote access via VPNWeb and mobile, role-based permissions
Deployment modelNo installation, ongoing manual effortProject-based engineering, on-site serverCloud + field box; on-site installation can also be evaluated
Pricing modelNo license; cost is staff timeProject + license + maintenance contractQuote based on site and device scale

10 Questions to Ask Before You Buy

Whatever software you evaluate, ask for clear written answers to these questions.

  1. Which meters and protocols does it read directly (Modbus, M-Bus, BACnet, OSOS)?
  2. Can the read interval be set per site?
  3. When the internet drops, where does data wait, for how many days, and is it fully delivered when the link returns?
  4. Does it show consumption in ₺ using the actual tariff?
  5. Does it warn about reactive penalties and peak demand before the bill arrives?
  6. Does an alarm explain its cause, or just say "threshold exceeded"?
  7. Are electricity, water and gas on the same panel?
  8. Can consumption be allocated and billed to sub-tenants?
  9. Who owns the data; can it be exported to Excel/CSV?
  10. What drives the price, and how does it change as sites or devices are added?

The Pages Behind the Criteria

📡

OSOS Data

What the distribution company portal has and lacks: the what is OSOS article and the cross-check logic.

🔌

Meter Reading

How analyzers and meters are read: energy monitoring with Modbus.

🛡️

Data Assurance

When the connection drops, readings wait on the field box: data assurance.

🧾

Tenant Billing

Allocating consumption from sub-meters to tenants: sub-tenant billing.

Comparison Questions

What is the difference between energy monitoring software and SCADA?
SCADA is built to operate a facility: the operator sees live values, switches equipment and gets a warning when a threshold is crossed. Energy monitoring software looks at consumption from a management angle: it brings electricity, water and gas onto one panel, converts them to ₺ with the tariff and flags reactive penalties and budget deviation before the bill arrives. Neither replaces the other; most facilities run both.
Isn't the data on the distribution company's OSOS portal enough?
The OSOS portal shows only the distribution company's main meter; sub-meters, water and gas are not there, data arrives late and it raises no alarms. Energy monitoring software cross-checks its own meter readings against OSOS data, which also catches measurement errors.
When is tracking energy in Excel enough?
Excel works for a single site, a single meter and a monthly bill check. Once the meter count grows, consumption has to be allocated to tenants, or there is a reactive-penalty risk, manual tracking both takes time and shows problems only after the bill arrives.
Can energy monitoring software be added when SCADA or building automation already exists?
Yes. The field box joins the existing network; meters and analyzers are read over Modbus TCP/RTU, M-Bus or BACnet/IP. The existing system keeps running as it is.
What is the most critical criterion when choosing energy monitoring software?
Data reliability: if readings are not held on the field box when the connection drops and then delivered in full, reports and bills end up with gaps. Next come ₺-based reporting and alarms that explain their cause.

See 6S Teknoloji at Your Facility

Explore the system with your own data in a demo session.